It seems that dunking on GitHub is the flavour of the day. At the moment most of the social/news type things I tend to read are filled with the Ghostty news, as well as a small revival of posts and links to blog posts about all the recent outages. It's understandable. It does seem that something has shifted with GitHub in the last few months. While it hasn't been the site I used to enjoy for quite some time now, it just seems to be getting worse at the moment.
It's even pissing off the loyal AI enthusiasts with the Copilot changes.
As I read all of this I find myself mostly nodding along. For the most part I'm not finding that GitHub is getting in the way and stopping me from doing the things I want to do, and for the most part it does act as a vital tool that lets me get work done, and also lets me enjoy my longest-enjoyed hobby. On the other hand I couldn't help but sigh and think "yeah, I get why this is the time that people are done" when I opened up the PR page for this blog, just now, and saw this:
It does get me thinking about my relationship with GitHub, and how long I've been using it. As I've written before, I created my account back in 2008; I was within the first 30,000 users. While my use of it was only very occasional for quite a long time, for the last decade I've been constantly interacting with it. It is somewhere I visit constantly, not just to do work on my own projects, but to read what other people are doing. One of the first things I do every morning, when I sit down at my desk, is open my GitHub dashboard page and have a scroll through the feed to see what people I follow have been up to.
It's generally been the most fulfilling feed I've read.
But I'm also getting that feeling I got when I hung on to my Twitter account far longer than I really should have; not just because of the general vibe of "it's falling apart", but also other types of questionable behaviour. The degrading performance, the troubling business relationships, the over-emphasis on all things AI... it adds up.
There is a sense that some time ago was the time to move elsewhere as my sociable forge (probably around the time that Microsoft took over), and that not having done that, now is the second best time. But the effort of making that move is non-trivial and, quite frankly, I'd want to see where folk start to land, if they started to move away in any numbers at all. For me the real utility of GitHub isn't the "it's somewhere to store my shit" thing, it's the socially coding thing.
Then there's the follow-up problem: if some other forge was to become the next flavour of the decade, it too would probably end up suffering the same fate as GitHub.
Perhaps now is the time for me to start looking into options for collaborative code forges that offer the same sort of solution that Mastodon does for Twitter-like nattering.