Like most people, I imagine, I first ran into transient when first using magit. I took to it pretty quickly and it's always made sense to me as a user interface. But... I've never used it for any code I've ever written.

I think, incorrectly, I'd half assumed it was going to be some faff to set up, and of course for a good while it wasn't part of Emacs anyway. Given this, I'd always had it filed under the heading "that's so neat I'll give it a go one day but not at the moment".

Meanwhile... ever since I did the last big revamp of my Emacs configuration, I found myself leaning into a command binding approach that does the whole prefix-letter-letter thing. For reasons I can't actually remember I fell into the habit of using F121 as my chosen prefix key. As such, over the past 10 or so years (since I greatly overhauled my Emacs setup), I've got into setting up bindings for commands that follow this prefix convention.

So when I created blogmore.el I set up the commands following this pattern.

(use-package blogmore
  :ensure t
  :defer t
  :vc (:url "https://github.com/davep/blogmore.el" :rev :newest)
  :init
  (add-hook 'blogmore-new-post-hook #'end-it)
  (blogmore-work-on "blog.davep.org")
  :custom
  (blogmore-blogs
   '(("blog.davep.org" "~/write/davep.github.com/content/posts/")
     ("seen-by.davep.dev" "~/write/seen-by/content/posts/")))
  :bind
  ("<f12> b b" . blogmore-work-on)
  ("<f12> b n" . blogmore-new)
  ("<f12> b e" . blogmore-edit)
  ("<f12> b d" . blogmore-toggle-draft)
  ("<f12> b s c" . blogmore-set-category)
  ("<f12> b a t" . blogmore-add-tag)
  ("<f12> b u d" . blogmore-update-date)
  ("<f12> b u m" . blogmore-update-modified)
  ("<f12> b l p" . blogmore-link-post)
  ("<f12> b l c" . blogmore-link-category)
  ("<f12> b l t" . blogmore-link-tag))

It works well, it makes it nice and easy to remember the bindings, etc. Nobody needs me to sell them on the merits of this approach.

Then I got to thinking last night: why am I setting up all those bindings when I could probably do it all via a transient? So that was the moment to actually RTFM and get it going. The first version was incredibly quick to get up and running and I was kicking myself that I'd taken so long to actually look at the package properly.

This morning I've worked on it a little more and the final form is still pretty straightforward.

(transient-define-prefix blogmore ()
  "Show a transient for BlogMore commands."
  [:description
   (lambda ()
     (format "BlogMore: %s\n"
             (if (blogmore--chosen-blog-sans-error)
                 (blogmore--blog-title)
               "No blog selected")))
   ["Blog"
    ("b"  "Select blog" blogmore-work-on)]
   ["Post"
    ("n" "New post" blogmore-new :inapt-if-not blogmore--chosen-blog-sans-error)
    ("e" "Edit post" blogmore-edit :inapt-if-not blogmore--chosen-blog-sans-error)
    ("d" "Toggle draft status" blogmore-toggle-draft :inapt-if-not blogmore--blog-post-p)
    ("c" "Set post category" blogmore-set-category :inapt-if-not blogmore--blog-post-p)
    ("t" "Add tag" blogmore-add-tag :inapt-if-not blogmore--blog-post-p)
    ("u d" "Update date" blogmore-update-date :inapt-if-not blogmore--blog-post-p)
    ("u m" "Update modified date" blogmore-update-modified :inapt-if-not blogmore--blog-post-p)]
   ["Links"
    ("l c" "Link to a category" blogmore-link-category :inapt-if-not blogmore--blog-post-p)
    ("l p" "Link to a post" blogmore-link-post :inapt-if-not blogmore--blog-post-p)
    ("l t" "Link to a tag" blogmore-link-tag :inapt-if-not blogmore--blog-post-p)]])

With this in place I can simplify my use-package quite a bit, just binding a single key to run blogmore.

(use-package blogmore
  :ensure t
  :defer t
  :vc (:url "https://github.com/davep/blogmore.el" :rev :newest)
  :init
  (add-hook 'blogmore-new-post-hook #'end-it)
  (blogmore-work-on "blog.davep.org")
  :custom
  (blogmore-blogs
   '(("blog.davep.org" "~/write/davep.github.com/content/posts/")
     ("seen-by.davep.dev" "~/write/seen-by/content/posts/")))
  :bind
  ("<f12> b" . blogmore))

Now, when I'm working on a blog post, I can just hit F12 b and I get a neat menu:

BlogMore with all commands available

Better still, because of how transient works, I can ensure that only applicable commands are available, while still showing them all. So if I've not even got a blog selected yet:

With no commands available

Or with a blog selected but not actually working on a post yet:

With some commands available

So far I'm really liking this approach, and I'm tempted to lean into transient more with some of my packages now. While on the surface it does seem that it has the downside of the binding choices being dictated by me, the fact is that the commands are all still there and anyone can use their own bindings, or I guess override the transient itself and do their own thing.

  1. Yes, it is a bit out of the way on the keyboard, but so is Esc. I find my muscle memory has no problem with it. ↩